It's down a side street in downtown, but I didn't have a hard time finding it because of the great big flag hanging above the door. The restaurant itself looks small from the outside but is actually three floors. The downstairs is mostly the bar, with a few tables. The second floor is all tables and the third table has a few tables and another bar. Here is the view up the stairs to the second floor, which I thought was quite lovely with skylights. It would be beautiful on a summer night.
I arrived earlier than Emily so I ordered a drink at the bar. I must say their selection of beers on tap left much to be desired. I ended up just getting a Bud Light bottle. I did not get carded...however when Em got there and ordered a drink and she didn't get carded even though she is older than me! I must have looked haggard :(
We decided to split an order of what Max and Dylan's is famous for, the mac n cheese. We went with the basic mac n cheese with toasted garlic crumbs.
In case you didn't already know, garlic is my second foodie love (behind cookies obvs) and the mac n cheese was creamy and delicious. I would've liked a stronger garlic flavor, but other than that, it was amazing.
For my entree, I ordered the Grilled Chicken sandwich with the housemade potato chips. The sandwich was just what I had expected. It was yummy but nothing really special. The chips however, were a little burnt (which I love) and were really the star of the show.
We opted out of dessert, because to be honest, the dessert menu was SERIOUSLY lacking. I base my quality of a restaurant on their dessert menu, so the fact that a sweet lover like me couldn't even find one thing remotely appealing on the menu, there has to be a problem. Hear me Max and Dylan? Add a fruit crisp or bread pudding or something.
All in all, I was pleased with Max and Dylan's but not blown away. I would go again just because it was close and convenient to my work and because the mac n cheese and chips make it worth the 15 minute walk.
What's the best mac n cheese you've ever had? Have you ever had housemade potato chips?